alcohol ale beer Beverages brettanomyces brewery brewing brewpub drinks Food and Fashion funky How Food Works lactic acid lacto lactobacillus lager libations local beer sour summer tart yeast

Beer Science: Sour and Funky Beers

Sour Beer close up WM 3

Sour Beer close up WM 3

Sour beer isn’t a brand new idea; in reality, the earliest beers have been in all probability all bitter by immediately’s requirements. That is largely because of the wild yeasts and micro organism that might infiltrate old-world open-container brewing methods and add their very own distinctive flavors to the brew. Ultimately, these wild flavors and bitter notes have been phased out as brewers improved their sanitation strategies and started utilizing closed containers and chrome steel. Holding wild yeasts and micro organism out allowed brewers to decide on particular yeast and micro organism strains, which meant the flavour and alcohol content material of their beer can be extra predictable.

As a common rule, having a predicable recipe is an effective factor, however shouldn’t we be capable of have our cake and eat it too? Over the centuries, brewmasters have labored to isolate the precise strains of micro organism and yeast that made these historic beers so good, and omit all those that made them so dangerous. As soon as upon a time, bitter beers have been manufactured by just a few specialised breweries in Belgium and Germany, however in recent times, small breweries everywhere in the world have begun experimenting with bitter beers. And the place good beer goes (haha, Gose?) individuals will comply with. In the end, bitter beers have earned a small however thirsty following in America, and I’m proud to be amongst them.

Beer pouringI used to be impressed to write down about bitter beers a couple of weeks in the past after attending a bitter beer tasting occasion, referred to as Sour Beer Takeover, on the Historic Sixth & I Synagogue in Washington, DC. In reality, as soon as I began writing, I couldn’t cease–which suggests I’ll be doling out the bitter beer love in two installments. The primary installment, under, is concerning the science of bitter beer (and common beer too). It’s an excellent primer for the beer nerd in all of us. The second installment, to be posted subsequent week, will spotlight a number of the superb native brews I tasted on the occasion. It’ll come full with my critiques and rankings, in addition to some enjoyable tidbits from the occasion. However for now, let’s get right down to the science and uncover how a humble grain of barley turns into a refreshing bitter beer. (Protip: you may need to pour your self a chilly one earlier than studying on.)

Beer Science

All beer begins with grain. Typically, that’s both solely barley, or a mixture of grains (like barley, wheat or corn). Grains are made up of principally starch, which is the beginning materials for beer. Starches are principally lengthy chains of sugar molecules, and these sugars are what are wanted for fermentation (and alcohol manufacturing) to happen. The trick of turning grain into beer is breaking these starches down into small, easy fermentable sugars, like glucose. The primary a number of steps in brewing are geared towards separating as lots of these small, easy sugars as potential.

Malted grain sm


Malting is step one in turning grain into beer. The uncooked grain is dampened with heat water and allowed to sprout (germinate). Malt is outlined as germinated grain. Germination triggers the manufacturing of an enzyme, referred to as amylase, which instantly begins changing starch into usable sugars. Beneath totally different circumstances, the younger plant may use these sugars to assist it develop, however since this little sprout is meant for brewing, these sugars are going to go towards a nobler trigger–beer. As soon as the sprouts have grown to roughly three-quarters of an inch, the malt is drained and roasted in a kiln, which stops the work of the amylase enzyme. Malt could also be roasted till it’s mild, darkish, or black. The roast degree of the malt is what determines the colour and malt taste of the ultimate beer. One other wrinkle that sometimes comes into play at this stage is smoke. As an alternative of roasting in a kiln, some malts are dried over smoking woodchips. Smoked malt is what provides Rauchbiers (smoked beers) their smoky taste. Smoked beers are comparatively uncommon, however some sours, together with a two of the native brews I’ll point out in my second installment, are smoked so as to add heat and character.

Brewing science: Starches are transformed to fermentable sugars by way of enzymes and warmth.
Taste results: Malting itself modifications the flavour of the ultimate beer, as is evidenced by the marginally totally different taste of unmalted beers. The stability of barley to different grains in addition to the extent to which the malt is roasted or smoked determines the colour and remaining maltiness of the beer.


As soon as the malt is absolutely roasted, it’s floor right into a mash and added to a tank referred to as a mash tun. Right here, it’s churned with water and heated, additional breaking down starches into fermentable sugars. Longer mash time often means extra fermentable sugars. Shorter mash time means extra unfermentable starches and different compounds, which give beer extra physique. The cooked mash is then transferred to a brand new vessel, the place the solids are allowed to settle to the underside.

Brewing science: Starches are transformed to fermentable sugars by way of warmth and agitation.
Taste results: Brews that spend extra time within the mash tun have a tendency to finish up with extra flavors from alcohol and different fermentation merchandise, however have a lighter physique than people who spend much less time there.

Hop sm


The liquid portion of the mash, referred to as the wort is drained off and moved to a kettle. Flavorful hops (and another botanicals) are added presently, and the wort is boiled. This kills any pre-existing microorganisms, resembling yeasts, micro organism, and molds which may spoil the beer or introduce undesirable flavors. Boiling additionally helps break down a few of the remaining unfermentable compounds and develops the malt and hop flavors. As soon as the wort is sterilized, it’s strained, cooled, and transferred to a fermentation vat. Strained wort is principally unfermented beer.

Brewing science: Wild microorganisms are boiled off. Hops even have some anti-microbial results that assist sterilize the beer. A couple of extra starches are transformed to sugar by way of warmth and agitation.
Taste results: Hops add their waxy, bitter, resinous, citrusy notes to the brew, together with some other botanicals (e.g. orange peel or coriander). This technique of taste infusion is just like steeping tea. Sterilization of the wort prevents off flavors from creating throughout fermentation.

Wort w Hops WM sm

Principal Fermentation

That is the place the magic occurs! The steps up till this level have centered on maximizing the quantity of sugar we will draw out of our grain. Sugars are necessary as a result of they drive fermentation. Fermentation microbes want sugar with a view to produce alcohol, carbon dioxide (CO2), and scrumptious taste and aroma compounds. Up till this stage, the method of creating bitter beer has been largely interchangeable with making common beer, however fermentation modifications every part. The distinction between bitter and common beers has all the things to do with which strains of micro organism and yeast are chosen for fermentation. Listed here are the microbial MVP’s you’ll see most frequently in bitter beers:

  • Lactobacillus (aka “Lacto”) – A micro organism which produces lactic acid, the most typical supply of sourness in bitter beer. There are two Lacto sub-types essential to bitter beer:
    • homofermentative, which solely produce lactic acid, and
    • heterofermentative, which produce lactic acid, acetic acid (vinegary), alcohol, CO2, and different taste and aroma compounds.
  • Brettanomyces (aka “Brett”) – A yeast which produces alcohol, CO2, and number of unusual and funky taste and aroma compounds. These compounds will range based mostly on the precise pressure of Brett used, and what the temperature and different environmental circumstances are throughout fermentation. Examples of some sought-after Brett flavors and aromas embrace fruit, citrus, barnyard, vinous (wine-like), musk, and butter. Brett might typically produce some sourness as properly, however to not the extent of Lacto.
  • Prime-fermenting Saccharomyces cerevisiae (aka “ale yeast”) – The yeast used to make common ales. It imparts no sourness, solely alcohol, CO2, and common ale-like taste and aroma compounds.
  • Backside-fermenting Saccharomyces cerevisiae (aka “lager yeast” or “beer yeast”) – The yeast used to make common lagers. It imparts no sourness, solely alcohol, CO2, and common lager-like taste and aroma compounds.

As you may think, common beer is brewed utilizing solely ale yeast or lager yeast. The truth is, the fascinating character imparted by Brett is taken into account an off-flavor in common beer. I point out them right here as MVP’s for bitter beer as a result of most bitter beer brewers select to make use of a mix of fermentation microbes, together with the common tasting ones, to realize the right stability of flavors. Principal fermentation can progress in any variety of methods. Sour beers are sometimes separated into totally different batches or fermentation levels as a result of every microbe requires its personal particular circumstances to thrive.

Yeast and Lacto Fermentation (anaerobic) vert WM sm

If the brewer decides to make use of multiple of those fermenting microbes, he’s doubtless to decide on one of many following two fermentation procedures: (1) separate the sterile wort between a number of small vats and inoculate every one with a special microbe; or (2) put all of the sterile wort into one massive vat and add the varied microbes one by one, sterilizing between every change.

BrettAnna Y. Myces 4 smIf the brewer chooses choice 1 (separate vats), one vat would get Lacto; one other would get Brett and so on. Every beer can be fermented individually, and then blended again collectively on the finish. This feature is good as a result of it doesn’t require any mid-fermentation sterilization. Each batch is allowed to ferment in peace; nevertheless, it requires more room and gear than many small breweries are capable of spare for a single beer.

If the brewer chooses choice 2 (single vat with one microbe at a time), he would transfer all of his sterile wort into one huge fermentation vat and inoculate it together with his first microbe–typically a homofermentative Lacto. The micro organism would eat sugar and produce lactic acid till the beer reached the brewer’s desired acidity degree. Lacto fermentation would then be halted by boiling off the micro organism. The newly sterilized, partially-fermented (now bitter) beer would then be inoculated with a yeast to complete off the remaining sugars within the beer. For a easy, clean-tasting bitter beer, the brewer may select an ale or lager yeast. For funky fruity bitter beer, he would doubtless select Brett.

The CO2 produced throughout fermentation is collected and saved to be added again into the beer at a later stage.

Brewing science: Microbes ferment nearly all of sugars into alcohol, CO2, acids, flavors, and aromas. Sour beer fermentation MVP’s are Lacto micro organism, Brett yeast, and (to a lesser extent) ale and lager yeasts.
Taste results: Extra Lacto means extra sourness, extra Brett means extra funky fruitiness, extra ale or lager yeast means extra “clean” beer taste. Brewers can management the stability of those points by both brewing separate small batches of single-strain beer and mixing them on the finish, or they will ferment their beer in levels, sterilizing the beer in between inoculations.

Second Fermentation and Lagering (Resting)

After the principal fermentation, a lot of the heavy lifting is completed, and the younger bitter beer can now be allowed to relaxation in a storage tank. The beer is cooled drastically to sluggish the exercise of fermentation microbes and encourage giant particulates to settle out of answer. As sediment gathers on the underside of the tank, the beer turns into much less cloudy. It’s allowed to relaxation at this cool temperature for a number of weeks, months, or years relying on the beer. Throughout this resting interval, generally known as lagering, a sluggish second fermentation happens, additional enhancing the flavour of the beer and including carbonation. In sure kinds of beers, reminiscent of framboise, further fruit (or one other sugar supply) is added earlier than second fermentation to provide fermentation microbes a recent batch of sugar to work on.

Brewing science: Lingering sugars are fermented slowly at low temperatures. Cloudiness is lowered because of sedimentation. Taste mellows and modifications over time, and fermentation microbes should work more durable to seek out meals.
Taste results: Getting older permits the flavour of the beer to mellow and enhance. Newly shaped CO2 is trapped, enhancing the beer’s effervescence. Off-putting particulates settle out of answer.

Sour Beer Bottle sm

Carbonation, Packaging and Pasteurization

Now the beer is prepared for the ending touches. It might be filtered or centrifuged to enhance its readability, and CO2 (which was collected throughout principal fermentation) is now pumped again in. The beer is then packaged into kegs, cans, or bottles. Although only a few sugars stay within the beer, there stays the danger that fermentation may proceed throughout storage, probably inflicting a buildup of CO2 inside the packaging. This isn’t an issue for beer packaged in kegs, as kegs can stand up to astonishingly excessive quantities of strain (about 300 psi—for context, automotive tires are often inflated to about 32 psi). Nevertheless, cans and bottles aren’t as robust, in order that they’re pasteurized after packaging to kill off any remaining fermentation microbes. Pasteurization improves the steadiness and shelf lifetime of canned and bottled beers, however barely alters their taste. Some beers packaged in cans or bottles might stay unpasteurized if the brewery employs sterile filtration as an alternative. Sterile filtration bodily filters out yeast and another dwelling microbes as an alternative of killing them. This pasteurization work-around is how some brewers are allowed to explain their canned or bottled beer as “draft beer”.

Brewing science: Ultimate measures are taken to make clear the beer and add CO2 again in. Beer is packaged and sterilized (besides keg beer) to stop additional fermentation.
Taste results: Filtration removes any particulates which can detract from the looks or taste of the beer. Further CO2 modifications the physique and lightness of the beer, whereas growing “carbonated” style (barely tangy). Pasteurization of canned and bottled beers requires warmth, which barely modifications their taste and halts fermentation.

Now let’s all crack open a pleasant chilly Bud Mild to have fun our new-found information of bitter beers! Simply kidding. Listed here are a couple of sours I’ve present in my native beer shops which have contributed to my appreciation of bitter beers. It’s not at all an entire listing, however give any (or all!) of those a attempt and broaden your beer palate. If in case you have a favourite bitter beer, inform me within the feedback; I’d love to listen to your suggestions!

Festina Pêche – Dogfish Head Brewery
The Kimmie, The Yink & The Holy Gose – Anderson Valley Brewing Firm
Rodenbach – Brouwerij Rodenbach N.V.
Monk’s Café Flemish Sour Ale – Brouwerij Van Steenberge N.V.
Petrus Aged Pale – De Brabandere
Petrus Oud Bruin – De Brabandere
Petrus Aged Purple – De Brabandere



1. Grossman, H. J. Grossman’s Information to wines, beers, & spirits. (Scribner, 1983).

2. O’Brien, C., Engert, G., Zeender, N. & Roy, M. Sour Beer Takeover. (2014). at <>

three. Bennion, M. The science of meals. (Harper & Row, 1980).

four. Nummer, B. A. Brewing With Lactic Acid Micro organism. Extra Beer (2012). at <>

5. Wyeast Laboratories. What’s Yeast? Yeast Fundamentals at <>